A gay friend of mine in Hollywood shared a flyer on Facebook, warning friends that a wave of MAGA supporters would soon flood their gay-friendly neighborhood—a place where they’d find little support. This reminds me of the early 90s, when powerless queer activists, many of whom were dying of AIDS, flooded into suburban malls to hold “kiss-ins.” These protests demanded that straight people see them and know that they existed. Of course, the difference is stark. The activists in the malls were without political power and facing death, and the MAGA movement is close to holding power in every branch of our government.
What do we know about movements that emerge out of anger and frustration and sweep into power? What do we know about movements that are born out of high inflation, undervalued labor, the inability to purchase a home, and the hardship of simply trying to live comfortably? What do we know about these movements led by charismatic leaders who promise easy answers? We know that these movements can go off the rails. These movements, once with power, can create great amounts of suffering. History is full of examples of this on both the left and right sides of the political spectrum. We can look Italy’s fascists, Russia’s Bolsheviks, Germany’s Nazis, China’s Red Guards, and Iran’s theocrats. Power, without the guardrails that protect humanity, can be dangerous and inhumane.
What I want my Republican-voting friends to know is that those of us Americans who are scared right now are reacting to an imagined future based on these historical precedents. The reality in this moment that the MAGA movement is not there. In this moment what is true is that our democratic institutions are still standing, our free press is still standing, and our ability to voice our frustrations is still standing just fine. We must all work together to ensure that it stays this way.
My fears stem from the words coming from the head of the MAGA movement, Trump. He speaks of there being two sides, and not a single American people. He speaks of his desire to retaliate against perceived political enemies, instead of hearing everyone’s concerns. He scapegoats powerless demographics such as immigrants, instead of doing the hard work of governance and working with all parties. His words divide us, and are meant to divide us, instead of unite and heal us.
If we draw conclusions based on Trump’s words we can imagine a future like those from history’s darkest moments. For example, Trump says he wants to deport all of our undocumented immigrants. Mass deportation of 10 million people is not just unrealistic, it would devastate the industries that keep communities stable—from agriculture to healthcare—and lead to scenes that echo the horrors of the historical movements I mentioned above. All of those movements had their own internal “enemies” and their governments used camps, deportations, and prisons to reach their own ideas of national purity.
History shows that unchecked power can gradually erode democracy, often through small steps like weakening independent courts, silencing the free press, limiting other political parties, and chipping away at civil liberties. Over time, these steps accumulate and create irreversible changes.
Overly simplistic solutions like deporting our country’s lowest wage earners by the millions will create suffering that impacts everyone. In addition to harming the lives of those directly impacted, it will dramatically increase the labor shortage already impacting all American communities, drive inflation to heights we’ve never seen, and further destabilize our economy. I ask that we recognize the complexity in our economic situation and do not take comfort in simple solutions. Solutions that do not consider all perspectives will always be false.
Here are my prayers for the days ahead:
May Republican voters and Republican politicians not be blinded by political power, and may they work to protect the elements of our democratic system, which includes the free press, an independent court system, and the civil liberties of all people.
May Democratic voters and Democratic politicians notice when they’re caught in the imaginations of the future and stay grounded in the present moment, which is the only moment where true power lives.
Instead of looking to earthly powers, such as economic and political power, may Trump discover the true power, which is born in the spiritual depths, that can guide him to become a true leader that seeks to unite all people.
May we all focus more on the health of our families, our neighbors, and our immediate communities, and focus less on national politics.
May we also keep one eye trained on our elected politicians, keep in communication with them, and hold them to the highest standards of integrity and leadership.
May we all stay firmly anchored in our senses of touching, hearing, seeing, tasting, and smelling, which keep us rooted safely in our earthly reality, and which bring joy and pleasure to our lives.
May each of us prioritize our mental, physical, and spiritual health, and seek support from our friends, family, spiritual communities, and mental health professionals when outside support is needed.
May we all remember that anything that divides is false, and that that which unites supports life.
How can each of us, with our words and action, contribute to our nation to ensure that our future is compassionate, wise, and protects the freedoms that make our culture unique?
May we all remember to breathe deeply.